Would eliminate the Department of Sanitation and Streets and transfer its responsibilities to the Department of Public Works, among other changes. Proposition B requires a simple majority (50% + 1) to pass.
Fiscal Impact: Would result in estimated savings of approximately $3.5 million, beginning in fiscal year 2022-23, and decrease to $2.5 million in fiscal year 2024-25.
Next San Francisco County Measure: Proposition C
Pro:
Proponents of Proposition B argue this initiative improves upon the measure approved by voters two years ago to split up the Department of Public Works and create the Department of Sanitation and Streets with the promise of prioritizing street cleaning. They argue that Proposition B will keep Public Works as one department, saving millions of dollars every year—money that instead can be used to expand street cleaning services in neighborhoods across San Francisco.
A YES vote on this measure means: The Department of Sanitation and Streets would be eliminated and its responsibilities would be transferred to the Department of Public Works, among other changes.
OversightDoneRight.com (Campaign Website)
Con:
Opponents of Proposition B argue this measure takes the nonsensical step of entirely eliminating the brand new Department of Sanitation that residents just voted to create. They argue to let the independent Department of Sanitation do what it was created to do: power wash your sidewalks, clean up your streets, and open up new public restrooms with real focus and accountability, and without the meddling of politicians.
A NO vote on this measure means: The Department of Sanitation and Streets would not be eliminated and would retain its responsibilities.
Existing Law
In November 2020, the voters approved Proposition B, a Charter amendment that divided the Department of Public Works into two separate departments-a Department of Public Works and a Department of Sanitation and Streets. Under Proposition B, the Department of Public Works is responsible for designing, building, and improving the City's infrastructure and public right of way. The Director of Public Works must be qualified by either technical training or management experience in engineering or architecture. And the Department of Sanitation and Streets is responsible for sweeping streets and cleaning sidewalks, providing and maintaining sidewalk trash cans, removing graffiti and illegally dumped waste, and maintaining City buildings, public restrooms, and street trees.
Proposition B also established a commission to oversee each department-a Public Works Commission and a Sanitation and Streets Commission. Each commission must have five members: two appointed by the Board of Supervisors, two appointed by the Mayor subject to approval by the Board of Supervisors, and one appointed by the Controller subject to approval by the Board of Supervisors. Proposition B listed specific oversight duties for the two commissions, including duties related to regarding approval of departmental contracts and review of performance under those contracts, and review of staffing of departmental positions. Members of the commissions must have specified qualifications or backgrounds.
Under the transition rules in Proposition B, the Public Works Commission and the Sanitation and Streets Commission will come into existence in July 2022, and the Department of Sanitation and Streets will come into existence in October 2022. Proposition B also requires the Controller to conduct an annual analysis evaluating whether there are inefficiencies or waste in the two departments' administration, operations, or division of labor.
Amendments to Current Law
The proposed Charter amendment will eliminate the Department of Sanitation and Streets, and transfer all the powers and duties of that department back to the Department of Public Works.
The proposed Charter amendment will also modify the powers of the two commissions established by Proposition B. The Public Works Commission will have oversight authority over the Department of Public Works, including the power to set policy for the department except in areas within the policymaking jurisdiction of the Sanitation and Streets Commission. The Public Works Commission will also have authority to make recommendations to the Mayor for appointment of the department head, and to remove the department head. The proposed Charter amendment will remove the specific list of Commission duties related to contracts and staffing.
The Sanitation and Streets Commission will have more limited authority to hold hearings and set policy for the Department of Public Works regarding sanitation standards and protocols, and maintenance of the public right of way. The Commission will also have responsibility for evaluating data regarding the street and sidewalk conditions of the public right of way, and establishing minimum standards of cleanliness for the public right of way.
The proposed Charter amendment will also remove the required qualifications for members of the two commissions, and replace those requirements with a list of desirable qualifications for the commissioners. Even though the commissions' powers and the members' qualification requirements will change, the commissions will continue to exist uninterrupted, and the appointed members may continue to serve their current terms.
The proposed Charter amendment also will remove the requirement for the Controller to conduct an annual audit regarding waste and inefficiency in the two departments, but the Controller will retain the authority to audit the Department of Public Works.